Expensive versus cheap: Tchibo glove versus Castelli

Both gloves are designed for the transitional period and should work in a wide temperature range. They rely on a wind and water-repellent membrane, offer a touch function and have to be just as convincing on the handlebars as when operating a GPS computer or smartphone. The fit and cut are crucial, because only if a glove fits tightly enough without constricting will the feel on the cockpit remain precise. At the same time, the membrane must not appear stiff, otherwise the dexterity of the fingers will suffer.

The focus here is on protection against wind and moisture - it's hard to steer with clammy fingers. The touch function also separates good gloves from bad gloves: Just being able to tap is not enough, swipe gestures and zoom movements must also work unerringly when operating a GPS computer or smartphone. Equipment details such as non-slip silicone prints or reflective material round off the test impression. This is exactly what we tested in everyday use - when navigating, when stopping the recording and when quickly gripping the handlebars. This shows which glove can impress in all categories.

Our verdict on the Castelli Perfetto Light Glove

The Castelli glove impresses with very good workmanship, a sporty fit and precise touch operation that also reliably recognises pinch gestures. Grip and wind protection are strong, the thermal performance is suitable for sporty use. Typically Castelli, the glove is rather tight, and the price is significantly higher than that of the competitor from the discounter. In return, you get a high-quality product that feels noticeably better on the handlebars and has a clear advantage on long or fast rides. If you ride regularly and value comfort, control and touch precision, you can't go wrong with this glove.

What the Tchibo Windprotection glove can do

The Tchibo glove is a surprisingly good everyday companion at a mini price. The touch function works well, the grip is good and the long cuff reliably keeps out the wind. However, the glove is very large and the noticeable seams in the fingers can bother sensitive riders. The workmanship is solid, but not on a par with expensive brand models. For short distances, commuting or as an inexpensive spare, it is still perfectly usable. If you want to spend less and can live with small compromises in comfort, you get a lot of glove for your money.

The editorial team's conclusion

The comparison shows two gloves that fulfil similar tasks but have different strengths. Both provide reliable protection against wind and light rain and work well in the transitional period. The Castelli glove scores with a perfect fit, direct steering feel and very precise touch control. The Tchibo glove offers solid performance at a low price, fits more loosely and fulfils the most important requirements, but is less sensitive and not quite as cleanly finished. The decisive factor on the bike: if you want the perfect glove, invest more and opt for the Castelli; if you rarely ride in the transition period, have thicker fingers and can do without perfection, choose the Tchibo model and save many euros.