Double the price, double the grip? Tyres in the price check

Florentin Vesenbeckh

 · 01.04.2018

Double the price, double the grip? Tyres in the price checkPhoto: Wolfgang Watzke
Double the price, double the grip? Tyres in the price check
MTB tyres are the number one tuning part, but also the number one wear part. Is it worth reaching for expensive models? A test in the lab and in practice.

Costs 32.90 euros Continental's brand new Mountain King tyre in the low-cost Performance version. 62.90 euros must be paid for the top model with Black chilli almost twice as much! At first glance, the two MTB tyres are identical. Both foldable, both fully tubeless compatible, identical tread. What is the difference and, above all, is the investment really worth it?

  Same same but different: Only the BlackChili Compound label reveals the difference, which makes the tyre 30 euros more expensive.Photo: Florentin Vesenbeckh Same same but different: Only the BlackChili Compound label reveals the difference, which makes the tyre 30 euros more expensive.

Whether they are expensive or cheap is largely determined by production costs and material costs. Let's stay with the example of Continental: The top models, called Protection, are manufactured in Germany, including appropriate wages and working conditions. The cheaper models come from the Far East, as do almost all standard mountain bike tyres. At Continental, part of the money therefore also flows into the label "Made in Germany".

  Handmade in Germany. High-quality production, higher price. Is this noticeable in practice? We have tried it out.Photo: Florentin Vesenbeckh Handmade in Germany. High-quality production, higher price. Is this noticeable in practice? We have tried it out.

It continues with the raw materials, for example the rubber compounds. Most tyre treads consist of a mixture of natural rubber and man-made rubber, and the price differences between the raw materials are enormous. While inexpensive tyres are covered with a standard compound, most manufacturers use customised rubber for their expensive models. In concrete terms, this means that there is no difference between a tyre for cross-country or enduro use in the case of inexpensive tyres. With expensive bike tyres, the rubber compound for CC tyres is trimmed for rolling resistance, while grip and damping are optimised for enduro MTB tyres. This increases production costs. But what effect does this have on the riding characteristics of an MTB tyre?

  The guillotine in the test lab immediately exposes weaknesses in puncture protection. Does expensive equal safe?Photo: Florentin Vesenbeckh The guillotine in the test lab immediately exposes weaknesses in puncture protection. Does expensive equal safe?

Let's first take a look at the laboratory values. The Continental Mountain King Performance weighs 770 grams, the expensive protection version of the Mountain King around 715 grams. This is a significant difference for those who love grams, especially as the weight on the tyre counts double when accelerating. The next test relativises the advantage somewhat. The guillotine, which tests the puncture protection of the tyres, causes the expensive Conti to run out of air a little earlier than its cheaper counterpart. More weight brings more puncture protection - even high-quality materials cannot break this credo.

How do you like this article?
  On the roller test bench at Ralf Bohle, we determined the rolling resistance for all tyre pairings. Can the expensive tyres stand out from their cheaper counterparts?Photo: Florentin Vesenbeckh On the roller test bench at Ralf Bohle, we determined the rolling resistance for all tyre pairings. Can the expensive tyres stand out from their cheaper counterparts?

And what effect do the expensive rubber compounds have on the grip and traction of the tyres?

You can read the detailed test of ten tyre pairs from the touring/trail and cross country sector (e.g. Schwalbe Rocket Ron, Maxxis Ikon or Onza Canis) with all laboratory values and riding impressions here in BIKE 5/2018 - on newsstands from 3 April.

  The tyre test is just one of many exciting topics in BIKE 5/2018, which will be available from 3 April at newsagents, in the <a href="http://www.delius-klasing.de/zeitschriften" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">DK online shop</a> and as a digital edition for all end devices.Photo: BIKE Magazin The tyre test is just one of many exciting topics in BIKE 5/2018, which will be available from 3 April at newsagents, in the DK online shop and as a digital edition for all end devices.

Florentin Vesenbeckh has been on a mountain bike since he was ten years old. Even on his very first tour, he focussed on single trails - and even after more than 30 years in the saddle of an MTB, these are still the quintessence of biking for him. He spent his youth competing in various bike disciplines and later his cycling career was characterised by years as a riding technique coach. Professionally, the experienced test editor now focusses on e-mountainbikes. In recent years, the qualified sports scientist and trained journalist has tested over 300 bikes and more than 40 different motor systems in the laboratory and in practice.

Most read in category Components