Saddle test 2011

Stefan Frey

 · 10.04.2011

Saddle test 2011Photo: Unbekannt
Saddle test 2011
Seat discomfort spoils the tour for many bikers. No need to despair - you just need to find the saddle that fits under your bum. Our test will help you do just that.

The Sprint banana saddle on my 1977 Bonanza bike is probably the most comfortable thing my bum has ever sat on. I could cruise round the houses on it for hours and always had a grin on my face. No wonder with almost half a metre of fluffy seat. Today, less is more - the bum flatterers now come in a racing look. The BIKE test shows which saddle is right for you. We have extensively tested 18 new models.

The correct sitting position is crucial when looking for the right saddle. Before you get to work, you need to determine your individual sitting position. A few centimetres more or less saddle elevation has a significant effect on the inclination of the pelvis - and therefore on the width of the contact points on the saddle. The more stretched out you sit on the bike, the further the load moves inwards away from the sit bones, towards the pubic bone. A race saddle can therefore be up to three centimetres narrower than a touring model. Studies show that the sit bone distance varies between six and 16 centimetres for men and between nine and 17 centimetres for women. Therefore, the first thing to do when buying a saddle is to measure the width of the sit bones. If the saddle is too narrow, you will be sitting far to the outside, on the sloping sides of the saddle. The weight is shifted to the nose of the saddle - discomfort is inevitable.


The test results of these saddles can be found below as a PDF download:


- Gentlemen:

Fizik Tundra 2 Kium

KDRE Performance T-Rail

Pro Turnix Carbon

SDG Formula MTR

Selle Italia SLR XC Gel Flow

Selle San Marco Aspide Carbon FX

Selle SMP Dynamic

SQlab 611 Active

Syncros FL Carbon

Terry Fly GT

Velo Airthru Gel (BIKE Tip Price/Performance)

WTB Valcon

XLCAmbition


- Ladies:

Bontrager Evoke R WSD

Fizik Vesta

Pologo Nago Evo Dea

Selle Italia Diva

Terry Butterfly GTS

  If neither advice nor test saddles lead to the perfect saddle, you can use a modified caliper to estimate the effective saddle width.Photo: Unbekannt If neither advice nor test saddles lead to the perfect saddle, you can use a modified caliper to estimate the effective saddle width.  The rear of the saddle should be as rounded as possible so that it doesn't pull your trousers off on the descent.Photo: Unbekannt The rear of the saddle should be as rounded as possible so that it doesn't pull your trousers off on the descent.
How do you like this article?

Downloads:

Stefan Frey is from Lower Bavaria and loves the mossy, loamy trails of the Bavarian Forest as much as the rugged rock of the Dolomites. For technical descents, he is prepared to tackle almost any ascent - under his own steam. As an accessories specialist, he is the first port of call for questions about equipment and add-on parts, while as head of copywriting he sweeps the language crumbs from the pages of the BIKE print editions.

Most read in category Components