The good modulation helps in the search for grip. The lever feel and lever reach round off the overall package. Crashes do happen, and a brake lever does break off. Annoying. The XT levers, however, give me a particularly delicate impression. They have a predetermined breaking point so that the control unit is not damaged in the event of a fall. However, it feels very thin, too thin and breaks even in the event of light falls or contact with trees. I had to replace three levers in two months, even though the clamp was not tightened. Bad luck? Or could the levers be a bit more stable?
By the way: Replacing the lever is fairly easy without having to open the pipe. On YouTube you can find Explanatory videos in addition.
However, the replacement levers became too expensive for me in the long run, as only the entire encoder unit is available in Canada. Individual levers are not offered. So I ordered the Pro 120 MTB levers from FLO Motorsports. The Americans obviously know the problem and have developed their own levers for Shimano's XT brakes, which the manufacturer claims are unbreakable. The reason for this is the stronger, CNC-milled material and a spring that allows the lever to move forwards in the event of a fall. Due to the thinner design in the finger area, the feel of the lever does not quite match that of the originals. Nevertheless, I have yet to break a FLO lever.
Cost point129.90 US dollars including shipping from the USA.
Shimano XT - Price204 Euro (per brake)
STRENGTHS: Dosability, braking force, lever ergonomics
WEAKNESSES: Lever broken several times
Conclusion on the Shimano XT:
The Shimano XT is one of the best brakes on the market. The competition can't match its lever ergonomics. Weak point: The brake levers break too quickly.
